Simple budgeting tips, added weekly
Budgeting

Reselling Toys Can Earn Extra Cash This Holiday Season

Have toys your children have outgrown? Learn how to prepare them for sale, compare marketplace fees, spot seasonal demand…

Reselling toys for holiday cash can help families clear out items children have outgrown and bring in money before seasonal shopping peaks. Start with toys already at home, check which items buyers are seeking, and compare selling fees before choosing a marketplace. The final amount you keep depends on the platform and the sale.

Sort the toys before choosing where to sell

Look through closets, storage shelves and the garage for toys that are no longer used. Outgrown bicycles and baby toys are common candidates, but the best items to list are those that are complete, clean and in condition you can describe honestly. A box of toys that has been forgotten for years may contain something useful to another family, or a collectible with a different audience.

Before posting anything, separate potential listings from items that are damaged, missing important pieces or unsuitable for a child. Clean and disinfect toys that are in sellable condition, then inspect them again. Take note of visible wear and any missing parts. Clear, accurate descriptions help buyers decide whether an item suits their needs and can reduce disagreements after a sale.

Make a short inventory. Record each toy’s name, condition, included accessories and any packaging that remains. If several similar items are going up for sale, keeping their details straight will make it easier to answer questions and avoid mixing up orders. Set aside toys that need more cleaning rather than photographing them before they are ready.

A person checks the condition of a vintage Furby and trading cards before resale.

Once the items are ready, compare the possible places to sell them. Facebook Marketplace can connect local sellers and buyers. eBay, Poshmark and Mercari offer online selling options, while GoodBuy Gear focuses on secondhand children’s goods. A nearby thrift store or consignment shop may be another route. Each option involves a different balance of convenience, audience and costs.

For a local exchange, consider whether arranging a meeting and coordinating with a buyer is practical. For an online platform, check what details it requires for a listing and how the sale is handled. A nearby shop can avoid some of the work of managing individual online listings, though the amount paid to a seller and the shop’s terms should be confirmed directly. The source material does not provide fee schedules for GoodBuy Gear, Facebook Marketplace or local shops, so check their terms before deciding.

Reselling toys for holiday cash starts with demand

The toys most likely to attract attention can change from one holiday season to another. Research early rather than assuming that a toy popular in a previous year will still be in demand. Social media hashtags on Instagram and TikTok can help show what children and teens are discussing. Google search trends offer another way to gauge interest, while conversations with parents can reveal what is appearing on current gift lists.

These signals are useful for deciding what to investigate, not a promise that a particular toy will sell or bring a particular price. A trend may fade, and a popular item may be widely available. Before buying a discounted toy specifically to resell, compare the price you would pay with the amount buyers appear willing to spend. Account for platform fees and any other costs you know will apply. If the numbers do not leave a worthwhile amount after those deductions, the discount alone does not make the purchase a good resale opportunity.

For 2025, Labubu dolls were cited as a toy many children wanted. An item with strong demand can sometimes command a higher resale price, but that depends on what buyers are actually offering and on the item’s condition. Do not treat social media attention as evidence that every listing will sell at a premium. Look at current interest and set a realistic expectation before spending money on inventory.

Families can apply the same research to toys they already own. Search terms and conversations may help identify which items deserve a more detailed listing, but use the exact toy and its condition when judging interest. A broad trend is less useful than evidence that people are looking for the specific item being sold.

Compare platform fees before setting a price

Seller fees can take a noticeable share of a sale. The rates below are the figures provided for eBay, Poshmark and Mercari. Read each platform’s current rules before listing, since the detailed terms determine how a fee is calculated and may differ across types of sales.

PlatformSeller fee describedWhat to check
eBay13.6% of the total sale amount up to $7,500, calculated per item. The rate is 2.35% on the portion above $7,500. A final value fee of $0.30 applies to sales of $10 or less, and $0.40 applies to sales above $10.Work out which portion of the sale amount each percentage applies to, and whether the final value fee is relevant.
PoshmarkFor an order below $15, the fee is $2.95. For an order of $15 or more, the fee is 20% of the sale amount.Check which fee applies to the order amount and read the platform’s full seller terms.
Mercari10% of the item price and buyer paid shipping.Confirm how the fee is applied to the transaction and account for the shipping component.

The table makes one point clear: the listed price is not necessarily the amount a seller keeps. Before accepting an offer, use the platform’s fee calculation to estimate the amount left after its charges. For eBay, the stated percentage changes on the portion above $7,500, and the final value fee depends on whether the sale is $10 or less or above $10. Poshmark’s stated fee changes at $15. Mercari’s described fee includes buyer paid shipping in its calculation.

Do not compare platforms using a single headline percentage alone. A flat order fee can have a different effect on a lower priced sale than a percentage fee. A percentage charge also grows as the sale amount rises. Check the exact order total and the fee rules that apply to that listing rather than assuming the same calculation fits every toy.

There are no fee figures here for Facebook Marketplace, GoodBuy Gear, eBay alternatives or local consignment shops. Ask about commissions or other charges directly before making a choice. A shop may save time spent answering messages and arranging individual transactions, while an online listing may give a seller more control over how an item is presented. The terms and effort vary, so compare them against your own priorities.

Plan for safe transactions and tax records

Protect personal information when arranging a sale online. Share only what is needed to complete the transaction, and be cautious about requests for information unrelated to the sale. For an in person exchange arranged through an online service, meet in a public place. Some communities designate locations such as city hall or a library for these handoffs. Check whether a suitable location exists nearby and agree on the meeting details before leaving home.

Keep a record of sales and related information as you go. A simple inventory can track the item, sale amount, platform and fee. Save relevant transaction details so that you can review your activity later. The source material notes federal tax rules for sales made online and in person, and says that anyone earning more than $400 annually through all cumulative gig work, not only toy reselling, is required to file annual income taxes on total earnings.

That $400 figure concerns cumulative gig work in the source material, not just proceeds from one toy or one marketplace. If you sell through multiple platforms or have other gig income, consider the combined activity rather than looking at each sale in isolation. Tax rules can depend on a person’s circumstances, so consult Internal Revenue Service information or a qualified tax professional if you need help working out how the rules apply to you. Do not assume that an item sold in person is outside the rules described for online transactions.

Keep platform fees visible when reviewing income from sales. A gross sale amount and the amount left after platform charges are not the same figure. Maintaining the records at the time of each transaction can make it easier to distinguish them later and to answer questions about the activity. Check the platform’s own transaction history as well as your notes.

When donating or selling vintage toys makes sense

Selling is not the only way to clear space. Donating usable toys can support a charitable organization and help another family, though it does not provide cash at the time of donation. Before choosing an organization, look into its work and giving practices through Charity Watch, Charity Navigator, the Better Business Bureau or the BBB Wise Giving Alliance.

The source material notes that donated items may be used as deductions on a tax return. Whether a donation qualifies and what records are needed depend on the applicable tax rules and a person’s situation. Check Internal Revenue Service guidance rather than assuming every toy donation produces a tax benefit. If the possible deduction matters to your decision, keep a record of what you donated and seek reliable guidance on the requirements.

Some older toys may appeal to adult collectors as well as children. Trading cards, Happy Meal toys and Furbies from the 1990s and 2000s were identified as vintage items with resale interest. A Furby could bring up to $200 when resold today, according to the source material, but that is a possible high amount, not a guaranteed selling price for every model or condition.

Check a vintage toy carefully before listing it. Its condition, completeness and suitability for children matter, and some items may be better described for collectors than marketed as toys for young kids. Be precise about wear and what is included. If an item might be collectible, research the specific toy rather than relying on a general claim about vintage demand. A top price for one example should not become the expected price for another.

Donation, resale and keeping an item are separate choices. A toy that is clean and wanted by buyers may be worth listing. One that has limited resale appeal but remains usable could be a donation candidate. An item with uncertain condition deserves a closer inspection before either route. A little sorting at the start can prevent time spent listing toys that are unlikely to suit a buyer.

Which toys are worth listing before the holidays?

Begin with toys already in the home, then use current searches and parent conversations to identify promising listings. Compare fees and effort before choosing a platform, and make safety and recordkeeping part of the process. For vintage items, condition and collector interest can matter as much as the toy’s age.